See the Answer is the explanation
Explanation:
Introduction
Effective leadership plays a crucial role in the success of a business, especially in small enterprises where employee motivation, supplier management, and operational efficiency directly impact profitability. Leadership styles should be adaptable to different situations, team dynamics, and external challenges.
Sarah, the manager of a small cake shop, adopts the Contingency Approach to Leadership, which means she adjusts her leadership style based on the specific circumstances her business faces. This essay will first explain what the Contingency Approach is and then discuss how Sarah can apply it to ensure her cake shop thrives.
1. What is the Contingency Approach to Leadership? (5 Points)
Definition
The Contingency Approach to Leadership suggests that there is no single best way to lead-instead, the best leadership style depends on the situation. A leader must evaluate environmental factors, team capabilities, business challenges, and supplier relationships to determine the most effective leadership style.
Key Principles of the Contingency Approach
Situational Adaptability - Leaders must adjust their behavior based on the context, team skills, and challenges.
Flexibility in Decision-Making - Some situations require authoritative leadership, while others benefit from a collaborative approach.
Focus on Environmental Factors - External factors such as market trends, customer demand, and supplier reliability influence leadership decisions.
Influence of Team Maturity - The leadership approach changes depending on whether employees are highly skilled and independent or require supervision and guidance.
Example of the Contingency Approach
If Sarah's cake shop faces a sudden staff shortage, she may need to adopt a directive leadership style, giving clear instructions to manage the crisis.
If she is introducing a new product line, she might collaborate with her team, encouraging creativity and innovation.
2. How Sarah Can Use the Contingency Approach to Ensure Business Success (20 Points) Sarah's cake shop operates in a highly customer-focused industry where quality, efficiency, and customer service are essential. Applying the Contingency Approach effectively can help her improve operations, manage staff effectively, and strengthen supplier relationships.
(A) Adjusting Leadership Style for Employee Management
Sarah employs 8 staff members with varying skill levels, meaning she must tailor her leadership style to each employee's capabilities.

By adapting her approach to different staff members, Sarah ensures high productivity, job satisfaction, and skill development within her team.
(B) Supplier Relationship Management
Sarah's cake shop depends on local suppliers for ingredients such as flour, sugar, and dairy. A contingency approach helps her manage these relationships effectively:
Handling Reliable Suppliers (Low-Risk Situations)
Uses a collaborative leadership style, fostering strong long-term relationships.
Works closely with suppliers to negotiate bulk discounts and ensure high-quality ingredients.
Dealing with Supplier Disruptions (High-Risk Situations)
Uses directive leadership to make quick alternative sourcing decisions.
If a supplier fails to deliver ingredients on time, Sarah must quickly find replacements to keep operations running smoothly.
By adapting her approach based on supplier reliability, Sarah ensures consistent ingredient supply, cost efficiency, and business continuity.
(C) Responding to Business Challenges and Market Changes
The food industry is highly competitive, and Sarah must adjust her leadership approach to respond effectively to external challenges such as:
Seasonal Demand Fluctuations (Christmas, Weddings, Special Events)
Uses a participative approach, involving her team in planning for high-demand periods.
Encourages staff to suggest new cake designs, flavors, and promotional offers.
Handling Customer Complaints and Service Issues
Uses a customer-focused leadership approach, ensuring that employees prioritize customer satisfaction and feedback resolution.
Trains employees in effective communication and problem-solving.
Implementing New Technologies (e.g., Online Ordering System)
Uses a coaching approach, training staff step-by-step on the new system while gathering their feedback.
By staying flexible and responsive, Sarah ensures that her cake shop remains competitive, innovative, and customer-focused.
(D) Managing Workload and Crisis Situations
In any small business, unexpected crises can arise, such as staff shortages, equipment breakdowns, or raw material shortages. Sarah can use different leadership styles based on urgency:
Crisis Situations (e.g., Oven Malfunction, Sudden Staff Absences)
Uses a directive approach, giving clear instructions to ensure quick problem resolution.
Example: If a baker calls in sick on a busy day, Sarah reallocates tasks immediately to keep up with orders.
Daily Operations (Stable Work Conditions)
Uses a participative approach, allowing employees to contribute ideas for improving workflows and efficiency.
By using contingency-based leadership, Sarah ensures her cake shop runs smoothly under different circumstances.
(E) Encouraging Teamwork and Employee Motivation
A successful cake shop requires a motivated, engaged team. Sarah can use different leadership techniques to build a strong team culture:
Team Meetings and Brainstorming
Uses a democratic approach, encouraging employees to share creative cake designs and customer engagement strategies.
Recognizing Employee Achievements
Uses a supportive approach, rewarding employees for exceptional performance and customer service.
By adapting to different employee needs, Sarah builds a motivated, skilled, and loyal team, reducing turnover and improving overall performance.
Conclusion
The Contingency Approach to Leadership is an effective strategy for Sarah as it allows her to adapt to various challenges in her cake shop, ensuring smooth operations, strong supplier management, and motivated employees.
By modifying her leadership style based on the situation, employee skill levels, supplier performance, and business challenges, Sarah can:
✅ Develop a high-performing team by offering the right mix of guidance and independence.
✅ Manage supplier relationships effectively by adjusting her leadership approach based on reliability and market conditions.
✅ Handle operational challenges efficiently, ensuring business continuity and customer satisfaction.
Ultimately, flexibility and adaptability are key to her success, making the Contingency Approach an ideal leadership style for small business management.