Correct Answer:
See the Answer is the explanation
Explanation:
Overall explanation
Below you will find how you can plan and draft the essay. Remember this is an example of one way you could approach the question. At Level 6 the questions are much more open so your response may be completely different and that's okay.
Essay Plan
Intro - what is change management?
P1 - planned
P2 - incremental
P3 - revolutionary
Conclusion - planned is best
Example Essay
Change management is a set of processes and strategies aimed at helping an organization smoothly transition from its current state to a desired future state. Mohammed, the CEO of ABC Ltd, aims to transition his consultancy organization from traditional paper-based record-keeping to electronic systems. To navigate this change effectively, Mohammed can consider various change management approaches, each with their own advantages and disadvantages:
Planned Change: Planned change is a methodical and structured approach to implementing change. It involves careful planning, preparation, and a well-defined roadmap for transitioning from the old paper-based system to the new electronic one. It typically minimizes disruption and resistance by providing employees with a clear understanding of the process. Mohammed could use a Ghantt chart and other tools so that everyone knows what is happening when: for example he could introduce the electronic systems department by department, for example having the HR department use it first, then after a month roll it out to other departments.
Advantages: Planned change offers predictability and allows for detailed planning and risk management. It also offers the lowest disruption; it gives employees an option to adapt gradually, reducing disruptions to daily operations and since the change is well-communicated and organized, it can effectively address employee resistance.
Disadvantages: Slower Implementation: It may take time to implement planned changes fully, potentially delaying the realization of benefits.
Incremental Change: Incremental change involves making small, manageable changes over time. This approach prioritizes gradual progress and can be less disruptive, as employees adapt step by step. For ABC Ltd this may be that each employee gets access to the system to do some aspects of their job first, then after a while they gain access to another part of the system and so fourth, until all actions are completed electronically rather than on paper.
Advantages: As this change method involves several steps, it reduces potential resistance to the change. It also provides Mohammed with a lower risk: Smaller changes are easier to monitor and adjust, lowering the risk of implementation issues. If the electronic system has a bug, this can be fixed quickly before doing away with the old paper system.
Disadvantages: The main disadvantage to this approach is similar to that of the planned approach- there is a prolonged transition: implementing changes incrementally may extend the transition period, delaying the full benefits.
Revolutionary Change: Revolutionary change entails a swift and complete shift from the old system to the new one. It aims for rapid transformation but can be highly disruptive and stressful for employees. This means Mohammed would introduce the system without warning, overnight.
Advantages: Revolutionary change can lead to quick results and immediate benefits. It is possible that employees may be more committed to using the new system due to the sense of urgency associated with this approach. They don't get a choice or time to moan about the change- they have to simply get on and use the new system.
Disadvantages: High Disruption: The speed of change may lead to stress, resistance, and potential issues. It also comes with a higher risk of Failure: inadequate planning and adjustment time can increase the risk of implementation failure. If the new system has bugs, but Mohammed has done away with the old paper-based system, this may result in staff not being able to do any work.
Conclusion:
In the context of ABC Ltd's transition to electronic record-keeping, a planned change approach appears to be the most suitable. This approach offers a methodical, structured, and predictable transition process. It allows Mohammed to carefully plan and manage risks while minimizing disruptions to daily operations. Additionally, it is well-equipped to address any resistance that may arise during the change process. Considering these advantages, a planned change approach aligns well with the organization's need for a smooth and effective transition to electronic systems while ensuring the best chance for success.
Tutor Notes
- This question asks you to pick one of the options, so don't sit on the fence here. Of those listed, planned or incremental would probably be the obvious choice, as revolutionary change is really risky for this scenario. Revolutionary change is associated more with responding to emergencies or creative tasks, rather than introducing a new IT system. Introducing an IT system really should be done slowly, as it allows time to sort any issues and get people on board and trained using it.
- A question on different types of change could also ask about emergent change- so make sure you're familiar with this as well.